The resident, identified as Resident #31, had registered a dangerously low blood glucose level of 40 mg/dl that same morning. Normal blood sugar levels typically range between 80-130 mg/dl for diabetics.
When the resident asked for food around midnight, the nursing assistant responded by telling him to shut up and go to sleep, adding "there was nothing to eat," according to the complaint investigation completed October 30.
The facility immediately suspended the nursing assistant pending investigation after the resident reported the incident. Administrators also notified the charge nurse, supervisor, and director of nursing, then contacted the sheriff's office per mandatory reporting requirements.
But the facility's internal investigation found no witnesses or corroborating evidence to support the resident's allegation. Administrators interviewed the resident, the accused nursing assistant, and other staff members who were working that night.
The facility concluded there was "insufficient evidence to substantiate the allegation of verbal mistreatment" and documented that "no physical or emotional harm identified in the resident."
Federal inspectors disagreed. They cited the facility for failing to protect residents from verbal mistreatment, classifying the violation as causing "minimal harm or potential for actual harm" affecting "few" residents.
The inspection report noted the resident "had also expressed his frustration regarding the incident." The timing of the verbal mistreatment became particularly concerning given the resident's medical condition earlier that day.
A blood glucose reading of 40 mg/dl indicates severe hypoglycemia, which can cause confusion, irritability, and intense hunger. Left untreated, such low blood sugar levels can lead to seizures, loss of consciousness, or even death.
The resident's request for food at midnight likely reflected his body's attempt to correct the dangerous blood sugar imbalance from earlier in the day. Diabetic patients often require snacks or meals outside regular dining hours to maintain stable glucose levels.
The facility's investigation process followed standard protocols. Administrators ensured the resident's immediate safety and provided reassurance that his complaint would be properly investigated according to facility policy.
The nursing assistant remained suspended throughout the investigation to protect resident safety and maintain impartiality in the process. The facility also reported the incident to local law enforcement as required by mandatory reporting guidelines.
Despite finding insufficient evidence internally, the facility's handling of the incident drew federal scrutiny. Inspectors determined the response failed to adequately protect residents from potential verbal mistreatment.
The citation falls under federal regulations requiring nursing homes to protect residents from all forms of abuse, including verbal mistreatment by staff members. Facilities must maintain policies and procedures to prevent such incidents and respond appropriately when allegations arise.
Willow Tree Healthcare Center operates at 1263 South George Street in Charles Town. The complaint-based inspection was completed October 30, focusing specifically on the alleged verbal mistreatment incident.
The facility's internal investigation interviewed multiple staff members present during the overnight shift when the incident allegedly occurred. None of the other employees reported witnessing the verbal exchange between the nursing assistant and resident.
The resident's frustration with the incident persisted even after the facility's investigation concluded. His complaint ultimately triggered the federal inspection that resulted in the citation for inadequate protection from verbal mistreatment.
The case highlights ongoing challenges nursing homes face in investigating allegations when no witnesses are present. Facilities must balance protecting residents from potential abuse while ensuring fair treatment of accused employees.
Federal regulations require nursing homes to immediately investigate any allegations of mistreatment and take appropriate action to protect residents. The standards apply regardless of whether internal investigations substantiate specific allegations.
The inspection found the facility's response, while following some protocols, failed to adequately ensure residents remained protected from verbal mistreatment. The citation specifically noted the minimal harm or potential for harm to residents.
Resident #31's medical vulnerability that day made the alleged verbal response particularly troubling to federal inspectors. His dangerously low blood sugar levels and subsequent midnight food request created a situation requiring careful staff attention rather than dismissive treatment.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Willow Tree Healthcare Center from 2025-10-30 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
Additional Resources
- View all inspection reports for Willow Tree Healthcare Center
- Browse all WV nursing home inspections