Medical records told a different story.
The same day the resident's blood glucose crashed, doctors at Willow Tree Healthcare Center discontinued his previous insulin order and wrote a new one reducing his dose from 38 units to 30 units. They also ordered staff to give him "a small snack of crackers and cheese before bedtime to prevent hypoglycemia."
The Assistant Director of Nursing told state investigators on October 28 that facility staff "had been unaware of the incident" until the resident filed his complaint on October 20. But the medical orders dated October 17 proved the facility knew immediately what had happened and why.
The resident had asked for food around 1 or 2 a.m. on October 16, hours before his blood sugar would crash. A nursing assistant told him there were no sandwiches available, but the resident later complained that the aide had told him to "shut up and go to bed."
Licensed Practical Nurse #11 backed up the nursing assistant's version of events in a written statement dated October 21. "I never heard [the nursing assistant] tell resident to shut up," she wrote. "Resident had asked for a sandwich, [the nursing assistant] asked me if we had any. I stated that we don't have any sandwiches."
The nursing assistant, who had worked as an aide for 32 years, denied telling the resident to shut up. "I may have told him to try to get some sleep which I tell a lot of residents to try to get some sleep," she wrote in her October 20 statement. "I've been a NA for 32 years and have never told a resident to shut up."
But someone had told the resident's roommate about the incident. When investigators interviewed Resident #30 on October 28, he said he had been out of the facility on October 16 but "heard about it when I got back."
The facility suspended the nursing assistant pending investigation and reported the incident to the sheriff's office. Their five-day follow-up report to state authorities, submitted October 22, concluded there was "insufficient evidence to substantiate the allegation of verbal mistreatment."
The investigation summary stated that "no witnesses or corroborating evidence were found to support the allegation" and that "no physical or emotional harm identified in the resident."
Federal investigators found that conclusion problematic. The resident had presented with a blood glucose level of 40 — a reading that can cause confusion, seizures, or even coma — on the morning after the incident. Normal blood glucose levels typically range from 80 to 130.
Despite this dangerous medical event and the resident's expressed frustration about his treatment, facility administrators maintained in their report that no harm had occurred.
The contradiction between the facility's public stance and their private actions was stark. While telling state investigators they knew nothing about any incident until October 20, medical staff had immediately adjusted the resident's insulin regimen on October 17 and added preventive measures specifically designed to avoid future episodes of dangerously low blood sugar.
The timing suggests facility staff understood the connection between the resident's request for food in the early morning hours and his subsequent hypoglycemic episode. Diabetic patients often experience nighttime drops in blood glucose, and a bedtime snack is a standard intervention to prevent such episodes.
The facility's investigation focused entirely on whether the nursing assistant had used inappropriate language, while overlooking the medical crisis that had prompted the resident's complaint in the first place. The resident's blood sugar reading of 40 represented a potentially life-threatening emergency, yet administrators described the incident as causing no physical harm.
Federal investigators cited the facility for failing to ensure residents were free from verbal mistreatment and for inadequate investigation of the incident. The violation carried a determination of "minimal harm or potential for actual harm" affecting "few" residents.
The case highlights how nursing home investigations can miss the broader context of resident complaints. A diabetic resident asking for food at 1 a.m. and then experiencing severe hypoglycemia hours later represents a medical emergency requiring immediate attention and thorough investigation.
Instead, the facility treated it as a he-said-she-said dispute about whether staff had been rude, while simultaneously taking medical actions that proved they understood the seriousness of what had occurred.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Willow Tree Healthcare Center from 2025-10-30 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
Additional Resources
- View all inspection reports for Willow Tree Healthcare Center
- Browse all WV nursing home inspections