Country Lane Gardens Rehab & Nursing Center failed to immediately report the October 29 incident involving two residents near an elevator, federal inspectors found during a November 26 complaint investigation. The violation represents continued non-compliance from an October 15 survey at the facility.
The incident began when Resident #3 started yelling at Resident #49, who was standing by the elevator while Resident #3 sat nearby in a chair. According to a handwritten statement by LPN #303, who witnessed the altercation, Resident #3 told Resident #49 to move away from him.
Both residents stood up. Resident #3 continued yelling and pushed Resident #49.
The licensed practical nurse immediately separated the residents and told Resident #3 to go to his room and calm down. Resident #3 argued for several minutes before eventually complying.
Minutes later, Resident #3 returned to the nurse and showed his hand, claiming Resident #49 had hit him.
"No he didn't hit you — you hit him," the nurse responded. "I was watching you."
The facility's Regional Director of Nursing was unable to provide clear information about when the incident was reported or when she became aware of the abuse allegation during the federal inspection. She could not verify whether the incident documented in nursing notes at 5:44 AM on October 29 was reported immediately, as required by facility policy.
Multiple nursing statements were filed about the incident. A nursing note was entered at 5:44 AM on October 29, followed by an additional statement at 5:38 PM the same day about Resident #3 pushing a resident. A Certified Nursing Assistant statement revealed the incident occurred around supper time on October 29.
The facility eventually reported the incident to the state agency at 8:55 PM on October 29 — potentially hours after it occurred.
During the inspection, the Regional Director of Nursing provided two handwritten statements she had completed on October 30, claiming both Resident #3 and Resident #49 could not recall the events. She also provided the October 29 statement from LPN #303, who no longer works at the facility.
The Regional Director of Nursing then revealed that the witness statements by both residents and the LPN had been discovered lying on the unit manager's desk and were not initially included in the information provided to inspectors.
The facility's abuse and neglect policy, dated November 1, 2019, explicitly requires staff to immediately report all allegations of abuse, neglect, exploitation, and mistreatment to the administrator or designee and to the Ohio Department of Health.
"Facility staff should immediately report all such allegations to the Administrator/designee and to the Ohio Department of Health in accordance with the procedures in this policy," the policy states. "All incidents and allegations of abuse, neglect, exploitation, mistreatment of a resident must be reported immediately to the administrator or designee."
The failure to immediately report the resident-on-resident violence violated federal regulations requiring nursing homes to protect residents from abuse and ensure proper reporting procedures. The deficiency affected few residents but carried the potential for actual harm.
Federal inspectors classified the violation as continued non-compliance, indicating the facility had previously failed to meet reporting requirements during an October 15 survey. The repeated failure to properly handle abuse reporting suggests systemic problems with the facility's incident management procedures.
LPN #303's detailed account of the incident provided the clearest picture of what occurred. The nurse witnessed Resident #3 initiate the confrontation by yelling at Resident #49, saw the physical pushing, and immediately intervened to separate the residents. When Resident #3 later tried to claim he was the victim, the nurse directly contradicted his account based on what she had observed.
The fact that crucial witness statements sat unnoticed on a manager's desk for weeks raises questions about the facility's documentation and communication systems. The Regional Director of Nursing's inability to provide clear information about reporting timelines during the federal inspection suggests confusion about basic incident response protocols.
Country Lane Gardens' repeated compliance failures indicate ongoing challenges with meeting federal safety requirements. The facility's struggle to properly document, report, and investigate resident-on-resident incidents puts vulnerable residents at risk and violates their right to a safe living environment.
The November inspection occurred in response to a complaint, suggesting concerns about the facility's handling of resident safety issues had reached state regulators. The discovery of misfiled witness statements and unclear reporting timelines during the investigation revealed deeper problems with the facility's incident management systems.
For residents and families at Country Lane Gardens, the violations highlight the importance of proper abuse reporting and investigation procedures. When nursing homes fail to immediately report incidents or lose track of witness statements, residents remain vulnerable to continued harm and families may not receive timely notification of safety concerns affecting their loved ones.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Country Lane Gardens Rehab & Nursing Ctr from 2025-11-26 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
Additional Resources
- View all inspection reports for Country Lane Gardens Rehab & Nursing Ctr
- Browse all OH nursing home inspections