Durango Health: Dementia Patients Fight, Staff Shortage - CO

The aide told federal inspectors she had witnessed the altercation between the two residents but often left one of them alone because "he was known to hit staff and get aggressive." She said she "followed him around all day with the mop bucket" because he urinated throughout the facility.

Resident #3, the victim of the assault, sustained a left eyebrow scratch during the fight. The 78-year-old patient had moderate dementia and required extensive assistance with daily activities. His care plan noted he had a history of getting into other residents' personal space, particularly those he perceived to be male.

The assailant, Resident #4, was severely cognitively impaired with a dementia assessment score of zero out of 15 points. The patient had Lewy body dementia, hypertension and depression. Despite his profound cognitive decline, facility records from February 2026 indicated he did not have behaviors directed toward other residents.

That assessment contradicted his actual care plans. A behavior plan from January 2025 documented that Resident #4 was at risk for "verbally abusive behaviors" and had "potential for psychosocial issues due to an incident of receiving unprovoked agitation with physical abuse from another resident."

A separate medication care plan from July 2025 identified him as at risk for aggressive behaviors, including "throwing medications, cursing at others, and non-redirectable agitation." The plan instructed staff to intervene immediately when agitation was observed to prevent escalating behaviors.

The lone certified nurse aide on duty described the challenges of working alone with seven dementia patients. "It was very hard at times, especially when the residents had moods, which was pretty often," she told inspectors during a March 31, 2026 interview.

She said when residents' behaviors increased, her job became even more difficult. The aide explained that Resident #3 was particularly challenging because he urinated throughout the unit, requiring constant cleanup. Rather than provide direct supervision, she said she "let him do his thing" because of his history of aggression toward staff.

The aide acknowledged she had seen Resident #3 get into other residents' personal space frequently, though she said he was not typically aggressive toward other patients. However, she noted that Resident #4 "did not like it when others got in his space."

A registered nurse who also worked on the unit corroborated the staffing concerns. During her March 30 interview, she told inspectors there was typically one staff member responsible for seven residents on the unit.

"At times it was hard, as she tried to complete personal care with the residents and keep an eye on them too," according to the inspection report. The nurse said she had observed residents getting into each other's space and confirmed that fights did occur.

The director of nursing acknowledged during her March 31 interview that she was involved with abuse investigations at the facility. She confirmed that the November 26 incident between the two residents was substantiated because of the injury to Resident #3.

Despite the documented fight and injury, the facility's response appeared limited. The director said the facility "monitored and redirected residents away from each other as part of the interventions for safety."

The incident highlighted the contradiction between Resident #4's documented care needs and the facility's assessment of his behavior risks. While his care plans from 2025 specifically identified aggressive behaviors and the need for immediate intervention during agitation, the February 2026 assessment indicated he posed no behavioral threat to other residents.

Resident #3's care plan acknowledged his tendency to encroach on other residents' personal space, particularly male residents, and called for staff to provide "positive interaction" and attention by "stopping and talking with the resident while passing by."

However, the single aide responsible for seven residents described a different reality. She spent much of her time following Resident #3 with cleaning equipment rather than providing the therapeutic interaction his care plan required.

The understaffing created a situation where the aide made tactical decisions about which residents to supervise directly. Her choice to give Resident #3 space to avoid his aggression toward staff left him unsupervised to wander into other residents' areas.

The November fight occurred despite both residents having documented care plans that should have prevented the altercation. Resident #3's plan called for staff intervention when he approached others inappropriately, while Resident #4's plan required immediate response to signs of agitation.

The certified nurse aide's admission that she witnessed the fist fight but had been leaving one resident unsupervised raised questions about whether proper interventions were attempted before the violence escalated.

Federal inspectors found the incident represented minimal harm with potential for actual harm to residents. The investigation was triggered by a complaint to state regulators about conditions at Durango Health and Rehabilitation.

The facility's approach to managing residents with dementia-related behavioral issues relied heavily on a single staff member's ability to simultaneously provide personal care, maintain environmental safety, and monitor multiple patients with complex needs.

Resident #3 continued to require constant supervision for his incontinence issues, with the aide describing her daily routine of following him with cleaning supplies. Meanwhile, Resident #4 remained on antipsychotic medications for behavioral management, with care plans acknowledging his potential for aggressive outbursts.

The director of nursing's confirmation that the abuse allegation was substantiated meant the facility had determined that one resident had indeed harmed another under circumstances that could have been prevented with appropriate supervision and intervention.

Full Inspection Report

The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Durango Health and Rehabilitation from 2026-03-31 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.

Additional Resources

• View all inspection reports for Durango Health and Rehabilitation
• Browse all CO nursing home inspections