Resident #5 first reported left leg pain on September 17, 2024, sometime between 4:00 PM and midnight. Licensed Practical Nurse #1 gave the resident Tylenol and reported the complaint to a supervisor, who instructed the pain medication but apparently never documented an assessment.
The next morning brought more concerning symptoms. Registered Nurse Supervisor #1 found the resident complaining specifically of left hip pain during an assessment. When the supervisor palpated the area, the resident complained of pain. There was no visible swelling or bruising, but the resident showed limited movement.
Physician #3 was notified and ordered a STAT x-ray at approximately 8:37 AM on September 18, 2024.
The x-ray never happened.
STAT orders in nursing homes should be completed within four to eight hours, according to Registered Nurse Supervisor #1. But when the supervisor returned to work on September 19, more than 24 hours after the emergency x-ray was ordered, it still hadn't been done.
Only then was Physician #3 notified again, and only then did the doctor order the resident transferred to a hospital.
The hospital x-ray revealed what the nursing home had failed to discover: Resident #5 had a fracture.
During a follow-up interview in September 2025, Physician #3 provided more details about the examination that led to the STAT x-ray order. The doctor found shortening to the resident's left leg during the September 18 assessment, which raised immediate suspicion of a fracture. That's why the physician gave a verbal order for an emergency x-ray.
But the facility's electronic order system tells a different story about the urgency. The STAT x-ray order wasn't even entered into the computer system until September 19, 2024 — after Resident #5 had already been transferred to the hospital. Physician #3 said they weren't aware of this delay in entering the order.
The Director of Nursing investigated the incident and concluded that abuse and neglect did not occur. During a telephone interview in July 2025, the nursing director explained that the STAT x-ray should have been completed within six hours but suggested there "could have been a delay due to insurance verification needed."
When the x-ray technician failed to arrive on September 19, the facility finally sent the resident to the hospital.
The nursing director also revealed another documentation failure: Registered Nurse Supervisor #2, who was involved in the initial pain assessment, never documented their evaluation in the resident's chart.
Multiple staff members interviewed about the incident showed concerning gaps in their recollections. Licensed Practical Nurse #1 couldn't remember when Registered Nurse Supervisor #2 arrived on the unit to assess the resident's initial pain complaint. Registered Nurse Supervisor #1 couldn't recall the specific time they were informed about the hip pain on September 18.
Physician #3 was "unsure of when they were notified" of the resident's pain complaints and couldn't remember the exact date of their examination. The doctor did recall that during the examination, the resident "did not display any signs of distress or pain," but the physical findings — specifically the leg shortening — indicated a fracture was likely.
The cascade of delays meant Resident #5 spent at least 24 hours with an undiagnosed fracture. The resident first complained of pain on the evening of September 17. A STAT x-ray was ordered the morning of September 18. But the resident wasn't transferred to a hospital until September 19, when the emergency imaging still hadn't been completed.
Insurance verification delays, as suggested by the Director of Nursing, don't typically apply to STAT orders in nursing homes. These emergency orders are designed to be completed immediately because they indicate potential serious medical conditions requiring urgent diagnosis.
The failure to complete the STAT x-ray also meant the resident received inadequate pain management. While Tylenol was administered for the initial pain complaint, a fracture typically requires stronger pain medication and immediate medical intervention.
Federal inspectors found the facility violated regulations requiring adequate medical care and treatment. The deficiency was classified as causing "actual harm" to residents, with "few" residents affected.
The case raises questions about Northern Manhattan Rehabilitation's ability to respond to medical emergencies. A STAT x-ray order represents a physician's determination that immediate imaging is necessary to diagnose a potentially serious condition. The facility's failure to complete this basic diagnostic test for over 24 hours left a resident suffering with a fracture that could have been identified and treated much sooner.
The incident also highlights documentation problems that can complicate medical care. When Registered Nurse Supervisor #2 failed to document their assessment, it created gaps in the resident's medical record that could affect treatment decisions.
Multiple staff members' inability to recall basic details about timing and notifications suggests either inadequate attention to a medical emergency or poor record-keeping systems that would help staff remember critical events.
For Resident #5, the delays meant unnecessary suffering and a more complex medical situation. Hip fractures in elderly nursing home residents require prompt diagnosis and treatment to prevent complications and reduce pain. The 24-hour delay in identifying the fracture potentially worsened the resident's condition and recovery prospects.
The facility's investigation concluded no abuse or neglect occurred, but federal inspectors disagreed, finding the delayed medical care violated standards designed to protect nursing home residents from harm.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Northern Manhattan Rehabilitation and Nursing Ctr from 2025-10-16 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
Additional Resources
- View all inspection reports for Northern Manhattan Rehabilitation and Nursing Ctr
- Browse all NY nursing home inspections