The October 8 federal inspection revealed that facility staff had created a detailed care plan in January 2023 acknowledging that Resident 76 exhibited "sexual behavior-seeking physical affection from male residents" and had a "related need for attention." The plan's stated goal was that she "will only engage in sexual activity with consenting partners."
Despite this documented pattern, when Resident 76 had contact with Resident 161, administrators failed to recognize it as a potential abuse situation requiring investigation and state notification.
During the inspection, Resident 76 smiled when asked about Resident 161 and said "I liked him!" when investigators asked if he had touched her anywhere. The resident, who slurred her words while speaking, appeared pleasant but provided no additional details about the contact.
Her power of attorney told inspectors that Resident 76 "likes men and makes her own decisions" and visits the facility about once every two months.
The facility's care plan for Resident 76 included specific interventions designed to prevent inappropriate sexual behavior. Staff were instructed to "avoid conversations/television/radio that could encourage or initiate inappropriate behavior" and to "provide privacy/remove to a private area" when needed.
By April 2024, administrators had added another intervention requiring staff to "supervise in social gathering/recreation programs," suggesting the resident's behavior had continued despite the original plan.
But Resident 161's conduct extended beyond sexual contact. Records show he engaged in a pattern of verbal abuse directed at other residents that facility staff witnessed but failed to properly address.
On November 27, 2024, RN 94 documented finding Resident 161 and another resident, Resident 53, positioned outside the doorway of room 704. Both were "yelling insults and curses into the room" at Resident 119, who lived there.
The nurse overheard Resident 161 shout "stick your finger up my ass" along with other profanity. When RN 94 asked them to stop the verbal assault, calling it "unacceptable," Resident 161 threatened her directly.
"Do you want to fight?" he asked the nurse.
Both residents refused to move away from Resident 119's doorway despite repeated requests. The nurse reported the incident to the charge nurse and social services, noting she would "continue to monitor" the situation.
Two weeks later, on December 11, the same nurse documented another confrontation between Resident 161 and Resident 119, describing them as "exchanging inappropriate insults."
When investigators interviewed Resident 119 during the October inspection, he confirmed the hostile encounters with Resident 161, calling him "an ass" and noting that "he is no longer here," indicating Resident 161 had since left the facility.
The facility logged both November and December incidents in their concern and grievance records. However, administrators failed to recognize the verbal assaults as resident-on-resident abuse requiring immediate investigation and reporting to the Ohio Department of Health's Long-Term Care division, known as OHFLAC.
Federal regulations require nursing homes to immediately report any suspected abuse to state authorities and conduct thorough investigations to prevent future incidents. The facility's failure to classify the verbal threats and sexual contact as abuse meant they never triggered these mandatory protections.
The inspection found that Peterson Rehabilitation "failed to investigate and failed to take appropriate action to ensure that the abuse would not continue."
This represents a breakdown in the facility's most basic resident protection systems. While staff documented concerning behaviors and even created intervention plans, they failed to connect individual incidents into a pattern of abuse requiring formal investigation.
The sexual contact between residents with documented behavioral issues, combined with witnessed verbal threats against other residents, should have prompted immediate administrative action. Instead, the facility treated these as routine behavioral management issues rather than potential crimes.
Resident 76's care plan acknowledged her vulnerability and need for supervision in social settings, yet the facility failed to protect her from unwanted contact. Similarly, Resident 119 endured repeated verbal assaults in his own room while staff logged complaints but took no meaningful protective action.
The inspection occurred nearly a year after the first documented incident, suggesting the pattern of inadequate response continued for months. By the time federal investigators arrived, Resident 161 had already left the facility, but the systemic failures in recognizing and responding to abuse remained.
Peterson Rehabilitation's handling of these incidents reflects broader problems in how nursing homes identify abuse. Staff may witness concerning behavior and even document it carefully, but without proper training and administrative oversight, facilities fail to recognize when individual incidents cross the line into reportable abuse.
The consequences extend beyond the immediate victims. When facilities fail to investigate and report abuse, they cannot implement effective prevention measures. Other vulnerable residents remain at risk from the same perpetrators or similar incidents.
Federal inspectors classified this as a violation causing "minimal harm or potential for actual harm" affecting "some" residents. However, the failure to investigate sexual contact involving a resident with documented behavioral issues and to address repeated verbal threats suggests the potential for more serious harm was significant.
The inspection report provides no indication that Peterson Rehabilitation has since improved its abuse recognition and reporting procedures, leaving questions about whether similar incidents would be properly handled in the future.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Peterson Rehabilitation and Healthcare from 2025-10-08 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
Additional Resources
- View all inspection reports for Peterson Rehabilitation and Healthcare
- Browse all WV nursing home inspections