Federal inspectors documented the violation during a September complaint investigation at Plainwell Pines Nursing and Rehabilitation Community, finding staff repeatedly left emergency call devices beyond residents' reach despite policies requiring the opposite.
Resident 104 had been admitted with diagnoses including dementia, lack of coordination, anxiety, muscle weakness, and difficulty walking. His medical history included a compression fracture of his first thoracic vertebra, where the bone had collapsed into a wedge shape in his upper back.
His care plan, revised in April, specifically identified him as "at risk for falls and subsequent injury related to dementia, decreased mobility, incontinence, malnutrition, failure to thrive, history of falls." The interventions called for staff to "provide verbal reminders to resident to call when needing assistance" and assist with positioning for fall precautions.
None of that mattered on August 20, when the resident returned from the local hospital's emergency room via stretcher. Progress notes at 6:11 PM documented that he was "alert and oriented" with no complaints of pain or discomfort. Staff noted he was lying with his call light in reach and a fall mattress in place.
But three weeks later, inspectors found a different reality.
On September 15 at 3:25 PM, they observed the same resident with his paddle call light bunched up behind his blankets at the foot of his bed, completely out of reach.
The pattern repeated with Resident 106, another man with dementia whose care plan identified identical fall risks. During multiple observations, inspectors documented his call light placed in various unreachable locations.
At 2:33 PM on September 15, he sat in a specialized scoot chair next to his bed while his call light lay on the center of his mattress, beyond his reach. Less than an hour later, inspectors found him in his wheelchair with the call light again placed in the middle of his bed.
The next day brought another violation. At 3:23 PM on September 16, Resident 106 sat in his broda chair while his call light hung off the side of the head of his bed, behind the chair's backrest and well out of his reach.
CNA T, interviewed by inspectors, acknowledged the basic safety requirements. Staff were supposed to ensure call lights stayed within reach, along with water, and beds should be lowered for safety. She explained that Resident 104 could drink water independently as long as staff placed the tray table over her lap and kept the water within reach.
Director of Nursing B reinforced the policy during her interview, stating that staff should ensure call lights remained in reach and all needs were met before leaving any resident's room.
The violations occurred despite both residents' documented histories of falls and mobility issues. Resident 104's thoracic compression fracture indicated previous trauma to his spine, while both men carried diagnoses of dementia that could impair their judgment about seeking help.
Federal inspectors classified the deficiency as having potential for minimal harm affecting some residents. The violation fell under regulations requiring nursing homes to ensure residents can easily summon assistance when needed.
The inspection narrative provided no details about whether either resident experienced additional falls or injuries during the period when their call lights remained out of reach. Progress notes from Resident 104's hospital return indicated he had no new medical orders, suggesting his emergency room visit resulted from a minor incident.
Both residents required specialized seating equipment, with Resident 106 using both a scoot chair and broda chair for positioning. These devices, designed for residents with limited mobility, typically indicate significant physical limitations that would make retrieving an out-of-reach call light impossible.
The facility's own care planning process had identified the specific interventions needed to prevent falls, including verbal reminders to call for assistance. Yet inspectors documented the opposite occurring across multiple days and different shifts.
Staff interviews revealed they understood the requirements but failed to follow through consistently. The gap between policy knowledge and actual practice left vulnerable residents without access to emergency assistance during periods when they sat alone in their rooms.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Plainwell Pines Nursing and Rehabilitation Communi from 2025-09-17 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
Additional Resources
- View all inspection reports for Plainwell Pines Nursing and Rehabilitation Communi
- Browse all MI nursing home inspections