HOMER, LA - A state inspection at Presbyterian Village of Homer revealed the nursing facility failed to properly notify a resident's family member about care planning meetings, preventing their participation in critical healthcare decisions for their cognitively impaired loved one.
Care Planning Violations Impact Vulnerable Resident
The Louisiana Department of Health cited the facility during a May 29, 2025 inspection for violating federal regulations requiring advance notification to residents and their responsible parties about care plan conferences. The violation affected a resident with severe cognitive impairment and multiple serious medical conditions.
According to the inspection report, Resident #27 had been admitted to the facility with diagnoses including seizure disorders, traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, anxiety disorder, hypertensive heart disease, depression, and a non-pressure chronic ulcer on their right foot. The resident's Brief Interview Mental Status (BIMS) score of 5 indicated severe cognitive impairment, making family involvement in care decisions particularly crucial.
The facility's own care plan policy explicitly states that residents and their legal guardians or family members must receive at least seven days' notice before care planning conferences. The policy emphasizes that these meetings should be scheduled at admission and continue at least quarterly, with the MDS Coordinator responsible for ensuring proper invitations are sent and documented.
Despite these clear requirements, the inspection revealed a complete breakdown in this notification process. When interviewed on May 27, 2025, the resident's family member reported "there had been no care plan meetings." This statement exposed not just a single missed notification, but an apparent pattern of excluding the family from the care planning process entirely.
Administrative Failures Confirmed by Staff
The scope of the facility's failure became clearer through staff interviews. The Social Services Director acknowledged to inspectors on May 28 that the resident's family was not being notified of upcoming care plan meetings. More troublingly, she admitted she did not have any care plan meeting announcements for the family because "they were not being done."
The MDS Nurse, interviewed on May 29, confirmed that the Social Services department held responsibility for notifying families about care plan meetings and sending invitations. This acknowledgment revealed a clear understanding of the proper procedures, making the failure to follow them particularly concerning.
Medical Significance of Family Exclusion
Care plan meetings serve as the cornerstone of individualized resident care in nursing facilities. These interdisciplinary conferences bring together medical professionals, nursing staff, therapy providers, social services, and dietary specialists to develop comprehensive strategies for each resident's needs. For a resident with severe cognitive impairment, family participation becomes essential for several critical reasons.
Cognitively impaired residents often cannot advocate for themselves or communicate their preferences, pain levels, or concerns effectively. Family members provide invaluable historical context about the resident's baseline functioning, personality traits, and pre-existing preferences that help staff distinguish between new symptoms and longstanding behaviors. This information proves particularly vital when managing complex conditions like seizure disorders, where subtle changes in behavior might signal medication effectiveness or emerging complications.
The resident's traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage history requires careful monitoring for neurological changes that family members might recognize more readily than staff who lack long-term familiarity with the individual. Similarly, managing multiple psychiatric conditions including ADHD, anxiety, and depression in someone with severe cognitive impairment demands nuanced understanding of the resident's typical presentation versus concerning changes.
Industry Standards and Regulatory Requirements
Federal regulations mandate family involvement in care planning as both a resident right and a quality assurance measure. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services established these requirements recognizing that optimal outcomes depend on collaborative care approaches. Facilities must maintain documentation proving they attempted to include families, even when relatives cannot attend in person.
Standard practice in quality nursing facilities includes multiple notification methods such as written invitations, phone calls, and follow-up reminders. Many facilities now offer virtual participation options, allowing family members to join via video conference when physical attendance proves impossible. The complete absence of any notification attempts at Presbyterian Village of Homer falls far below these industry standards.
The facility's own written policy aligned with best practices by requiring seven-day advance notice and offering flexibility in scheduling to accommodate family availability. The policy also appropriately recognized that participation could occur through various means including phone conversations and written input, not limiting involvement to physical attendance at scheduled meetings.
Additional Issues Identified
Beyond the primary violation regarding care plan notification, the inspection findings suggest broader systemic issues with the facility's care coordination processes. The Social Services Director's admission that meeting announcements were simply not being created points to organizational failures extending beyond a single resident's case.
The disconnect between the MDS Nurse's understanding of responsibility and the Social Services Director's acknowledgment of non-compliance indicates potential communication breakdowns between departments. Such interdepartmental confusion can lead to other critical tasks falling through administrative gaps.
Consequences for Resident Care
The failure to include family in care planning for a severely cognitively impaired resident with multiple complex medical conditions represents more than a paperwork violation. Without family input, staff may miss important behavioral cues, medication reactions, or comfort measures that could significantly impact the resident's quality of life and medical stability.
For residents with chronic wounds like Resident #27's foot ulcer, family observations about pain responses, positioning preferences, and historical healing patterns provide crucial information for wound care planning. Similarly, managing hypertensive heart disease requires understanding the resident's typical activity tolerance and recognizing subtle changes that might indicate cardiovascular decompensation.
The inspection classified this violation as having potential for "minimal harm or actual harm" and affecting "few" residents, suggesting inspectors found the issue limited to Resident #27 among the 28 sampled residents. However, the systemic nature of the failure, with staff openly acknowledging that notifications were not being done, raises concerns about whether other residents' families might also have been excluded from care planning processes.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Presbyterian Village of Homer from 2025-05-29 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
💬 Join the Discussion
Comments are moderated. Please keep discussions respectful and relevant to nursing home care quality.