MIDDLE VILLAGE, NY - A certified nursing assistant at Dry Harbor Nursing Home violated a cognitively impaired resident's privacy and dignity by filming and posting them on TikTok without consent, according to a federal inspection report released following a complaint investigation.
Privacy Violation Exposed Patient to Public View
The October 22, 2024 incident involved a nursing assistant who recorded and shared a video featuring a resident with severe cognitive impairment on the social media platform. The resident, diagnosed with non-Alzheimer's dementia, depression, and hypertension, had a Brief Interview of Mental Status score of three, indicating severely impaired cognition and inability to provide informed consent.
According to the facility's investigation, the nursing assistant admitted to posting the resident without obtaining proper authorization, stating they wanted to show "how great it was to be a certified nursing assistant" and because the resident "expressed appreciation." The post remained active for three days before being removed after receiving comments about potential Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) violations.
The violation came to light when another nursing assistant reported seeing the post on the offending employee's TikTok account. Risk management was immediately notified, triggering an internal investigation that confirmed the unauthorized social media posting.
Federal Privacy Protections for Nursing Home Residents
Nursing home residents maintain fundamental rights to privacy and dignity under federal regulations, regardless of their cognitive status. These protections become especially critical for residents with dementia or other cognitive impairments who cannot advocate for themselves or understand the implications of being recorded.
The facility's own policies explicitly prohibited staff from taking pictures or videos anywhere in the building, with clear guidelines stating that "residents cannot be viewed in the forefront or background of any picture or video." These policies exist to protect vulnerable populations who may not understand or remember giving consent, even if they appear cooperative during filming.
When residents have severe cognitive impairment, they cannot provide informed consent for activities like social media posting. Medical professionals recognize that cognitive assessment scores below 8 indicate significant impairment, making it impossible for affected individuals to understand the long-term consequences of having their image shared publicly online.
Immediate Response and Policy Updates
The facility took swift corrective action upon discovering the violation. The nursing assistant was terminated immediately on October 22, 2024, and the resident's next of kin was notified of the incident. Leadership conducted emergency meetings with department heads to address the breach and prevent future occurrences.
A comprehensive facility-wide training program was implemented starting the same day, covering dignity, social media policies, resident rights, corporate compliance, and HIPAA requirements. The facility achieved 94% staff completion, including 62.2% of registered nurses, 82% of licensed practical nurses, and 91.3% of certified nursing assistants.
The facility updated both its abuse prevention policy and employee handbook to explicitly prohibit social media posting involving residents. An emergency Quality Assurance and Performance Improvement meeting was held to formally report the incident to the New York State Department of Health.
Ongoing Monitoring and Prevention Measures
To prevent future violations, the facility implemented weekly social media audits of platforms including Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok. These monitoring efforts have found no additional unauthorized postings since the October incident.
During the January 2025 federal inspection, 14 staff members across multiple departments confirmed they had received training on social media policies and understood the prohibition against posting residents online. The compliance measures appeared effective, with no further concerns identified during the investigation.
Industry Standards for Resident Privacy
Healthcare facilities must maintain strict boundaries between personal social media use and patient care. Professional nursing standards emphasize that any recording or photographing of patients requires explicit consent, proper documentation, and legitimate medical or educational purposes.
The incident highlights the need for clear policies addressing social media use in healthcare settings. Modern nursing education increasingly emphasizes digital professionalism, recognizing that social media platforms can quickly amplify privacy violations beyond the intended audience.
Facilities serving cognitively impaired residents face additional responsibilities to protect those who cannot protect themselves. Legal guardians or family members typically hold decision-making authority for residents with severe dementia, making unauthorized recording particularly problematic from both ethical and legal perspectives.
Consequences and Compliance Restoration
The federal inspection classified this as a past noncompliance issue with minimal harm, noting that no negative effects on the resident's emotional, psychosocial, or physical well-being were documented. However, the violation still represents a serious breach of trust and federal privacy requirements.
The facility demonstrated compliance restoration through multiple corrective measures: immediate termination of the offending employee, comprehensive staff retraining, policy updates, ongoing monitoring, and transparent reporting to state authorities. Federal inspectors determined the facility had returned to substantial compliance by October 23, 2024.
This case underscores the critical importance of maintaining professional boundaries in healthcare settings, particularly when caring for vulnerable populations. The swift response and comprehensive corrective measures suggest the facility takes resident privacy seriously, though the initial violation highlights ongoing challenges in the social media age.
The incident serves as a reminder that healthcare workers must prioritize patient privacy over personal social media engagement, with particular vigilance required when caring for residents who cannot advocate for themselves or understand the implications of being recorded.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Dry Harbor Nursing Home from 2025-01-27 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
💬 Join the Discussion
Comments are moderated. Please keep discussions respectful and relevant to nursing home care quality.