MONROVIA, CA - Federal inspectors found that Monrovia Gardens Healthcare Center failed to provide adequate supervision and staffing, resulting in a resident fracturing their spine after an unwitnessed fall while left alone in a conference room.
Unsupervised High-Risk Resident Falls, Fractures Spine
The most serious violation involved a 12th-floor resident with multiple health conditions including heart failure, diabetes, and kidney disease requiring dialysis. This resident had a documented history of falls and was identified as high-risk, requiring frequent visual monitoring and placement near the nursing station for supervision.
On December 28, 2024, staff placed the resident in a wheelchair near the nursing station around 8:30 a.m. for monitoring. However, when a nursing assistant returned at noon, the resident was missing. The assistant found the resident alone on the floor of a closed conference room next to their wheelchair, with a large bump on their head.
"There was no staff supervising Resident 12 in the conference room and staff were unable to see Resident 12 in the conference room from the nursing station because the conference room door was closed," stated the nursing assistant who discovered the fall.
Hospital imaging revealed the resident had sustained a fracture through the dens - a critical part of the second cervical vertebra that helps support the head. The injury required a cervical collar and posed significant risks due to the resident's age and multiple medical conditions. Neurosurgical consultation determined the resident was too high-risk for surgery.
The facility's own care plans specifically required frequent visual checks and keeping this resident at the nursing station for immediate staff assistance. A Licensed Vocational Nurse acknowledged that "We (staff) did not follow Resident 12's care plans to monitor Resident 12 frequently."
Critical Staffing Shortages Create Care Delays
Federal inspectors documented systematic understaffing that resulted in residents waiting up to an hour for basic care. The facility's own assessment determined optimal staffing levels of 7-10 residents per aide during day shifts, 10-13 during evening shifts, and 12-16 during overnight hours.
However, assignment sheets revealed chronic violations of these standards across multiple dates in December 2024 and January 2025. On December 22, one overnight aide was assigned 29 residents while another managed 28 - nearly double the facility's maximum recommended ratio.
Residents reported significant delays in receiving assistance. One resident described waiting an hour for diaper changes, while another documented a 95-minute delay between reporting a bowel movement at 9 a.m. and receiving cleaning assistance at 10:25 a.m.
"The more residents the CNAs had to take care of, the longer it took for CNAs to answer the call lights and to assist other residents," explained one resident when describing the correlation between staffing levels and response times.
A nursing assistant confirmed the impact of excessive caseloads: "With 10 to 12 residents CNAs could not provide good care... residents would not get showered, residents would not get changed right away."
Staff Training Failures Result in Painful Care
The inspection also revealed that nursing assistants were not following proper techniques for repositioning residents, causing unnecessary pain during routine care. Two residents reported that staff pushed directly on their skin instead of using draw sheets - a basic safety technique taught in nursing aide training.
One resident with a hip prosthesis stated it was painful when assistants failed to use proper repositioning equipment. Another resident with spinal compression fractures described staff as "rough" during care, though clarified the assistants were "not intentionally rough just in a hurry."
The facility's own competency assessment documents specify using two people and a draw sheet to avoid skin shearing while repositioning residents. This technique protects vulnerable skin and reduces discomfort during necessary care activities.
Medical Context and Industry Standards
Falls in nursing homes can have devastating consequences, particularly for residents with multiple medical conditions. Cervical spine fractures like the one sustained by the resident are especially dangerous, as they can affect breathing, movement, and potentially be life-threatening. The specific type of fracture - through the dens of C2 - occurs in a critical area that helps stabilize the head and neck.
Proper fall prevention requires consistent implementation of individualized care plans. High-risk residents typically need visual monitoring every 1-2 hours and should remain in areas where staff can provide immediate assistance. The failure to maintain continuous supervision of a confused, high-fall-risk resident represents a fundamental breakdown in safety protocols.
Adequate staffing levels are essential for both fall prevention and basic care delivery. When aides are responsible for excessive numbers of residents, they cannot provide the frequent monitoring required for safety or respond promptly to calls for assistance. This creates cascading problems including increased fall risk, delayed hygiene care, and inadequate repositioning that can lead to pressure injuries.
Additional Issues Identified
Inspectors noted several other concerns including failure to follow proper body mechanics training for staff repositioning techniques and inconsistent implementation of individualized care plan interventions across different shifts and staff members.
The violations demonstrate systemic issues with both supervision protocols and staffing adequacy that directly impacted resident safety and quality of life.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Monrovia Gardens Healthcare Center from 2025-01-24 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
💬 Join the Discussion
Comments are moderated. Please keep discussions respectful and relevant to nursing home care quality.