Elm Manor Nursing: No Nurses for 38 Minutes - NY

The registered nurse had left at 10:26 AM. No replacement arrived until 11:04 AM. During those 38 minutes, residents needing insulin, pain medication, or emergency care had nobody qualified to help them.

This was just one snapshot from federal inspectors who spent a week in August documenting how chronic understaffing at the 46-bed facility put residents at risk. On multiple days, single nursing assistants handled the personal care of all 40 residents — bathing, toileting, feeding, and answering call bells across the entire building.

The facility's own staffing plan called for three certified nursing assistants on the day shift. Instead, on August 10th, one aide worked alone from 7 AM to 3 PM, responsible for helping residents dress, eat breakfast and lunch, use the bathroom, and maintain basic hygiene. The ratio was one aide to 40 residents.

Evening shifts proved even more dangerous. On July 29th and July 31st, a single nursing assistant covered the 3 PM to 11 PM shift, handling four scheduled showers plus all incontinence care, toileting, dinner service, and emergency calls. On August 1st, no nursing assistants worked from 7:15 PM to 9:45 PM, leaving two licensed practical nurses to provide all resident care including medications, treatments, and personal hygiene.

Resident #195 told inspectors the facility was understaffed and they waited a long time for care. The day before the interview, they had waited an hour for someone to answer their call bell.

"I cannot get up when I want to due to staffing challenges," Resident #17 explained during an August 21st interview.

The consequences played out in residents' rooms and hallways. On August 23rd, inspectors watched a red call light — signifying a resident needed bathroom assistance — glow above multiple rooms for 28 straight minutes. No staff member responded. No staff were visible in the hallway.

Resident #38 described a night shift incident from August 14th when they needed to use the restroom. Only one certified nursing assistant was working in the entire facility. It took over 30 minutes to get help. "This happens often," the resident told inspectors.

Family members noticed the neglect too. One visitor told inspectors their loved one was frequently incontinent because staff didn't arrive in time to provide toileting assistance. The family had repeatedly told staff their loved one's hair was dirty and needed a shower, but nothing happened.

The staffing crisis reached beyond basic care. On August 15th, the wound care physician couldn't complete rounds because no nurse was available to assist them. Occupational Therapist #1 told inspectors that resident care was often hindered by staffing shortages, making it difficult to work with residents who were soiled and hadn't received incontinence care.

Licensed Practical Nurse #2 revealed how staff adapted to impossible conditions. They pre-poured medications into cups to save time, knowing they would have to abandon their nursing duties to provide basic aide care when no assistants showed up for shifts.

"Often times they would have to transition from their role as a Licensed Practical Nurse and take on Certified Nursing Assistant duties due to staffing challenges," the nurse explained during an August 26th interview.

But pre-pouring medications created new dangers. Inspectors found four medication cups containing multiple pills sitting uncovered in a medication cart drawer, labeled only with room numbers. Licensed Practical Nurse #2 admitted they could only identify the medications by room numbers, meaning if a resident wandered into another room, they could receive the wrong person's medications.

"I had pre-poured my medications and was not aware that it was not good nursing practice to prepare medications and leave them in the medication cart," the nurse told inspectors. They said they had seen another nurse pre-pour medications before.

The Director of Nursing called the practice unacceptable. "No one should ever pre-pour medications," they said, noting that proper medication administration was covered in orientation and nurses were expected to follow safety protocols.

Management acknowledged the crisis. Licensed Practical Nurse Manager #1 told inspectors there were several shifts during July with no certified nursing assistants working at all. "Nursing Leadership and Administration were aware of staffing struggles," they said.

The Assistant Director of Nursing confirmed staff shortages but claimed the facility always had a nurse in the building. The August 15th incident proved otherwise.

Food safety suffered alongside resident care. Inspectors found six crates of milk stored at 54 degrees Fahrenheit in a chest freezer, well above the safe temperature of 45 degrees or below. The Food Service Director discarded the milk after inspectors discovered the violation.

In the kitchen, staff were thawing chicken patties in standing water without cold water running — a method that allows dangerous bacteria to multiply. The Food Service Director claimed the water had been running but someone else must have turned it off.

The Registered Dietician admitted temperature problems were ongoing. "Sometimes temperatures are not always what they should be," they told inspectors, noting that during recent test trays, milk was "a little warm" and the cooler's temperature knob "got hit sometimes."

Elm Manor's crisis reflects a broader staffing emergency across American nursing homes, but the facility's specific failures put individual residents at measurable risk. When Resident #38 needed bathroom help during the night and waited over 30 minutes, that wasn't a system problem — it was one person in pain, calling for help that didn't come.

The wound care physician who couldn't complete rounds on August 15th wasn't dealing with an administrative inconvenience. Without proper wound assessment and treatment, residents face infections, hospitalizations, and potentially life-threatening complications.

For 38 minutes that August morning, 40 vulnerable residents lived without any nurse in the building. Some needed insulin. Others required pain medication. A few might have been having medical emergencies. All of them had trusted this facility to keep them safe.

Nobody was there to help them.

Full Inspection Report

The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Elm Manor Nursing and Rehabilitation Center from 2024-08-27 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.

Additional Resources

• View all inspection reports for Elm Manor Nursing and Rehabilitation Center
• Browse all NY nursing home inspections