Elm Manor Nursing Home: Food Safety Failures - NY
An inspector pressed a Super-Fast Thermapen thermometer into one of the pint-sized cartons of 2% milk stored there and read 54 degrees Fahrenheit. The thermometer mounted inside the cooler confirmed it: the display showed above 50 degrees. Six square crates of pint-sized milks were sitting in that unit.
The Food Service Director, interviewed on the spot, said the temperature had been fine at 9 AM that morning. Then she voluntarily discarded the milk. The inspector, following standard protocol, calibrated the Thermapen in crushed ice and water. It read exactly 32 degrees. The thermometer was working correctly. The cooler was not.
Four days later, inspectors returned to the main kitchen and found a different problem. An eight-by-twelve-by-six-inch pan sat in the sink, filled with water and two bags of precooked chicken patties. The water was still. Nobody had left the cold tap running.
The Food Service Director explained that someone else in the kitchen must have turned the water off while plating food or cleaning up. She said the chicken had only been sitting there for about 45 minutes and turned the cold water back on while speaking with the inspector.
Proper thawing under running water requires continuous cold flow. Without it, the water in the pan warms to room temperature, and the surface of the food warms with it. The chicken patties were precooked, but improper thawing of any potentially hazardous food creates conditions for bacterial growth before the food ever reaches a resident's plate.
What made the milk finding harder to dismiss was what the Registered Dietician said the following morning. Interviewed on August 27, she told inspectors that the kitchen does test trays once a month and that temperatures are not always what they should be. She said she believed the last time a test tray was completed, the milk came back a little warm. Staff had tested the refrigerator afterward to confirm it was holding temperature.
Her explanation for the chest freezer: it looked like the temperature control knob got bumped sometimes.
A knob that gets hit sometimes, producing milk that runs warm sometimes, in a facility whose own monthly monitoring had already flagged the problem. The Registered Dietician did not say what corrective action had followed that earlier warm reading, or whether the cooler had been repaired or replaced.
Elm Manor's own dietary policy, dated November 2022, states that all foods are to be prepared by acceptable methods to maintain optimal nutritional value and that meals are to be served at the proper temperature. The milk stored at 54 degrees and the chicken sitting in a pan of standing water both fell short of that standard.
Inspectors cited the facility under New York State health code provisions governing food storage, preparation, distribution, and service. CMS classified the violations at a level of minimal harm or potential for actual harm, with some residents affected. The survey ran from August 21 through August 27, 2024.
The facility's plan of correction was not included in the inspection documents reviewed. For information on how Elm Manor intends to address these findings, CMS directs the public to contact the nursing home or the state survey agency directly.
What the records show is a kitchen where a temperature problem had already surfaced in monthly monitoring, where the explanation was a knob that gets bumped, and where the cooler was still running warm enough to push milk nearly ten degrees above the threshold for safe cold storage when inspectors arrived.
The residents eating in that dining room had no way to know any of it.
Full Inspection Report
The details above represent a summary of key findings. View the complete inspection report for Elm Manor Nursing and Rehabilitation Center from 2024-08-27 including all violations, facility responses, and corrective action plans.
Additional Resources
Data source: This article is based on inspection data downloaded directly from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) via Medicare.gov. CMS releases inspection reports in bulk; we publish the findings as documented by state surveyors in the official Form CMS-2567 Statement of Deficiencies.
Plan of correction: The CMS report we receive does not include the facility's plan of correction. Facilities submit plans of correction separately to state survey agencies and those responses may not be reflected in CMS data at the time of publication. The absence of a plan of correction in our data does not mean one was not filed. Readers who want information about corrective steps taken are encouraged to contact the facility directly or their state survey agency.
Corrections may have occurred: Inspection reports reflect conditions observed on the date of the survey. Facilities may have implemented corrections, staffing changes, additional training, or other remediation since the report was issued. We report what CMS provides and encourage readers to seek current information from the facility.
Editorial process: Inspection findings are extracted from CMS source documents and synthesized using AI, reviewed for factual accuracy against the original report by our editorial team.
Corrections: We strive for accuracy in everything we publish. If you believe any fact in this article is incorrect, please contact us with details, and we will review and correct it promptly.
Professional review: All content reviewed by Christopher F. Nesbitt, Sr., NH EMT & BU-trained Paralegal.
Last verified: November 22, 2026 · Our methodology
Elm Manor Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Canandaigua, NY was cited for violations during a health inspection on August 27, 2024.
An inspector pressed a Super-Fast Thermapen thermometer into one of the pint-sized cartons of 2% milk stored there and read 54 degrees Fahrenheit.
Health inspections identify deficiencies that facilities must correct. Violations range from minor documentation issues to serious safety concerns. Review the full report below for specific details and facility response.
